Check this out: the lovely Digital Parchment Services/Futures-Past Editions ad we will be running in the LOSCON Program Book ... featuring many SF books by current and past LASFS members ... like Arthur Byron Cover, William Rotsler, Charles Lee Jackson II, and Jack Jardine/Larry Maddock!
Showing posts with label hugo award. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hugo award. Show all posts
Friday, November 7, 2014
Monday, November 11, 2013
LOST INTERVIEW: FUTURISTIC MEDITATIONS FROM DUNE’S FRANK HERBERT Part II
Interview
by Jean Marie Stine
(This
never-before reprinted conversation was originally published in an
issue
of the L. A. Reader in mid-1984 (at the time of the Dune movie's release).
During our
post-interview conversation Frank, who was on his way to climb the
Himalayas with
Sherpa guides, mentioned that he had just written the outline for what
would be
the final Dune book and he and an attorney had put a copy in a safe
deposit box
until he returned just in case anything happened to him. On his way to
the Himalayas, Frank was diagnosed with a fast moving cancer, and passed
away a few months later. Twenty years on, I
discovered that no one in the Herbert family had known of the outline,
and that its
existence had only recently been discovered.)
PART II
JMS: The First Dune book (the one the movie was
based on) taken by itself seems pretty straightforward good guys vs. bad guys
stuff, with the good guys triumphing at the end. But in the second book you question a number
of assumptions you led the reader to make in the first book and you reveal a
much more complex and meaningful design than was apparent in the first book
alone.
HERBERT: The
first three books were one book in my head.
I wrote parts of the second two before I completed the first. In fact I wrote the last chapter of the first
one before I finished it. I did develop
the other two a bit more because I thought of new stuff. But when I finished that third book I thought
I was through with it. I had a theory. Charismatic leaders -- not necessarily
Messiahs, but Messiahs included -- tend to create explosive upheavals in human
societies which are very dangerous to individuals and to the societies
themselves, because they create power structures. So you get these centers of power and it
doesn't matter a damned bit how pure and good the hero is. By just being he creates a power structure
and so it's like a magnet: the iron filings, the corruptible, come in and
things are done in the name of the leader -- as they were done in Christianity,
in Islam, in Buddhism, in all major religions and lesser religions. Things done in the name of the leader are
amplified by the members, who follow without thinking, without questioning, and
you wind up in Guyana drinking poisoned Kool-Aid. So I wanted to create a charismatic leader
(Paul Muad-Dib, the hero of the novel and film), a Messiah you would follow for
all of the right reasons. He is loyal to
his people, he's honorable and he's true to his friends. Every characteristic that you could possibly
think of, including the prince in search of the Grail, is there in that
character -- you would follow him right into Camelot. And there is the power structure that grows
up around him; that's what we deal with in the second book. That shook a lot of people. Here was a hero who didn't make everything
all right * He created a power structure.
He did it just by being there.
JMS: In the
Dune books, you seem to question a number of other cultural assumptions. One of them is the belief that the
establishment of a democracy necessarily addresses all of humankind's problems
and needs.
HERBERT: One of the things I noticed as a reporter --
I was a journalist longer than I've been on this side of the table -- is that
in all the marching in the streets in the '60s, the people who were shouting
"Power to -the People" didn't mean power to the people. They meant "power to me and I'll tell
the people what to do." When you
questioned them it was confirmed at every turn.
Power
to the people will really happen when the people wake up to the fact that you
can't separate economics from politics, when they wake up to their own
motivations, what they want, what can be sold to them. Because the real pitfall of democracy is that
it is demagogue-prone. We like to have
people stand up and tell us what we want to hear. I have conditioned myself so that the minute
I hear a politician standing up there saying nice things that sound good to lot
of people my alarm signals go off and I say, "Why, you damned son of a
bitch, you're just another damned demagogue.
I
don't think there's a fucking bit of difference between a bureaucracy that is
instituted by a democratic regime, a state; socialist regime, a communist
regime or a capitalist regime. Take a
look at us right now. We have created a
bureaucracy in this country which is completely out of the hands of the people. Your votes do not touch it. One day when I was working in Washington,
D.C. as a speech-writer for a U.S. senator from Oregon, I was at a meeting of
the Department of Commerce and a very, very high department official, a
lifetime bureaucrat, was talking about another senator, who was giving them
some trouble. And this high bureaucrat
called this senator a "transient." And sure enough, that senator was
defeated in the next election. So he was
a transient. But the bureaucrat was,
still there, and he retired on a separate retirement system for the federal
bureaucracy.
People
ask me what I think about Reagan, or "Ray-gun," as I tend to call
him. Well, you know, he has several good
things going for him. Number one, we
know he's an actor. We tend not to think
about other politicians as actors. But
they all are. Mondale's an actor. I have good reports, accurate reports on him
offcamera. Offstage he can be a real
bastard to his people. You never see
that when the smiling man gets up in front of the camera. He depends on his analyses to tell him what
people want to hear. The other thing
about Reagan is that I think he's pretty much beyond the age where he's easily
corrupted. His foreign policy scares the
shit out of me, but as long as he's paranoid of the bureaucracy I'll stand
aside and applaud. And say, "Focus
on that baby!" For that much I like him.
JMS: How do
you feel we could put the power in the hands of the people?
HERBERT: Well,
I think there are several ways to do it.
Governments, being power centers, as I said before, attract the corrupt
and the corruptible. So we have to go
after the problem of how do we design our Governments, so that we attract
people who are not corruptible, or not easy to corrupt, anyway. The Romans solved it a long time ago. Before they got on their empire kick they
went out and got a leader and said, "You're the boss for a year or
two. But that's it!"
One
of the things I would do - If I could wave a magic wand - I would give us a
six-year presidency, 'no re-election. A
two-term, maximum four-year senator, and a one-term, four-year
congressman. If they can't discover how
the system works in Washington within a month of being there (hell, I
discovered within two weeks of working for a senator), then they aren't bright
enough to belong there. It's a privilege
to work for your society. Not a right,
not something earned by being there forever.
We have to keep them in for short terms, attract good people with high,
pay. And if I had my say about it, I'd
make it a criminal offense with long prison terms for any military officer to
accept a job with a defense after a retirement.
That's handing the fox the key to the henhouse and saying, "I'm
going to be gone for the night." That's an invitation to corruption, and
of course that's what we get.
We
have the instruments and we have the precedents for handing power back to the
people. I think government ought to be
an experience. You know, when this
government was formed it was called, worldwide, "The Great Experiment."
Somewhere along the line we carved it in stone.
Experiments are things you test and find out what's wrong with
them. Right?
I
would experiment with a process that is now available to us. I would call it something like "The
Great Theory." I would select at random, on the basis of those who voted
in the last election (we could do this easily now with computers), a rotating
core group of 13 good people to serve at all levels of government, high and
low. I would give them absolutely
awesome powers, leave them in office for one year, and I would make it damn
near a capital offense to interfere with the operations of this whole
thing. I would set it up so that they
had a budget, a sufficient budget, but no standing support facilities, no
continuing bureaucracies. Every new
committee would have to hire its own people and its own experts under a spoils
system. And, at very high levels, I
would give them the power of subpoena, the power to look in any place they
wanted to look without question - and the power to fire.
Now
let's go down to lowered levels. I
discussed this with a member of the bureaucracy in the state of Washington, an
official of the school system. He asked
me, "How would you apply this?" I said: "Well, let's go to the
local school district. Under my system
any time the local school district proposes to spend over X amount of dollars,
automatically such a review committee would be called into being. The members would be selected from among
those who voted in the previous election.
They'd have the power of life and death over that proposal, the power to
subpoena; they could go into the school system and examine the records back to
the dawn of history. They could look at
how the school system is operating, how it had been spending its money in the
past."
This
bureaucrat asked me, "Do you think they'll always make good
decisions?" And I said, "No.
But they'd only be there for a year and if they made a mistake it'd be
very apparent and the next committee could deal with it." His next reaction,
I thought, was just magnificent, very telling, almost like a classic Freudian
slip. He said: "Do you think some
damned housewife could understand what's going on in the school system that
well?" [Laughs] I said: "You bet your sweet bippy I do!" Because
if you put the responsibility on people, really put it on them, they rise to
the occasion.
I
would also make it impossible for any person who had served on one such
committee ever to serve on one again.
Once a lifetime. It would
completely turn around what we think of as the democratic system, because it
would make voting attractive. You'd want
to be in on the chance to be selected for this.
And you would know that one of you, somebody who voted, would be right
in the seat of power if the need arose. I
think it would -really give power to the people, which is what democracy is
supposed to be all about. Now all of the
closet aristocrats will come out of the closet when you propose this kind of
thing and say, "My God! At random
you're going to get some real dopes!" And I would say,.,@$What are the
statistical probabilities that you would get 13 real dopes? Maybe you will. Maybe the monkeys will type the great novel."
JMS: What are
the odds that you would get more dopes this way than by the present system?
HERBERT:
[Laughs] I'm willing to gamble. Now I'll
tell you something interesting in MY reading of history: Every time we have
pulled the lid off the human desire to govern our, own affairs, to be free of
government - we've had a renaissance of some kind. We've had a social -renaissance, we've had a
political renaissance, an artistic renaissance.
Every time in history we've unleashed this, we've gone forward by leaps
and bounds. So I'm saying, "All
right, this is what history says to me.
So why don't we do it again?" That's what I'm playing with in. the seventh
Dune book, moving toward showing the kind of governments that finally evolve
out of the situation I have created.
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Frank Riley, The Forgotten Hugo Winner
From the Introduction to our ebook collection "Project Hi-Psi"
Frank Riley (1915-1996) wrote such a meager number of science fiction stories (seven novelettes and one novel in collaboration with Mark Clifton) over such a short period of time (four years from 1954 to 1958) that it would seem unlikely he could have had any significant impact on the sf field at all. But, that one novel, They'd Rather Be Right (serialized in 1954 in Astounding, the most golden of all Golden Age sf pulps), won the Hugo Award for the Best Science Fiction Novel of the Year, and the modest handful of stories he produced helped set the pace for his fellow writers for years to come. Riley's first solo story, "The Cyber and Justice Holmes," was immediately selected for the annual "best science fiction of the year" anthology.
Frank Riley (1915-1996) wrote such a meager number of science fiction stories (seven novelettes and one novel in collaboration with Mark Clifton) over such a short period of time (four years from 1954 to 1958) that it would seem unlikely he could have had any significant impact on the sf field at all. But, that one novel, They'd Rather Be Right (serialized in 1954 in Astounding, the most golden of all Golden Age sf pulps), won the Hugo Award for the Best Science Fiction Novel of the Year, and the modest handful of stories he produced helped set the pace for his fellow writers for years to come. Riley's first solo story, "The Cyber and Justice Holmes," was immediately selected for the annual "best science fiction of the year" anthology.
The editors of the digest magazine, If: Worlds of Science Fiction, in which all his solo stories appeared, noted Riley's exceptional gifts, when they wrote in the August 1956 issue, where his novella "Project Hi-Psi" was appearing, that while he had been "writing science fiction for only two and a half years, his stuff has the maturity and easy-reading quality of the experienced craftsman." Frank Riley had learned that craftsmanship the hard way, putting in fifteen years as a newspaper journalist and magazine writer before turning to science fiction. Riley said that he preferred to write science fiction "because it offers challenge and opportunity."
At the time the above was written, Frank Riley reported that he had just "completed a new short novel, 'Abbr.,' which extrapolates the digest trend in our current culture." He also told If's editors that "the next two items on the fire are short stories, one of which, 'Eddie,' is based on a rather amazing incident in a CAA investigation of a recent air crash; the other is 'A Question of Identity,' based on a legal situation that may be facing our courts in another dozen years or so." Sadly, those three stories, plus the above mentioned "Cyber and Justice Holmes" and "Project Hi-Psi," along with two others, "Bright Islands" and "The Executioner," seven in all, represent Frank Riley's total output of science fiction stories – which is presented here in chronological order.
For all his excitement over the "challenge and opportunity" the sf field offered, Riley was about to receive an offer whose challenges and opportunities eclipsed for all time those of fiction writing, however rewarding. Soon Frank would be called by the Los Angeles Times, which would offer him a position as travel writer, whose job, accompanied by his brilliant wife Elfriede, would be to visit all the most fascinating and beautiful places in the world and bend his literary talents to reporting on and describing them. The result would be hundreds of prize-winning columns and several fascinating books of travel reminiscences, co-authored with Elfriede.
But it also meant that a mere seven novelettes by this Hugo Award winning author would be all the science fiction by Frank Riley we would ever have. Travel writing's gain was truly the sf field's loss. One that, with his passing, can now never be repaired.
Jean Marie Stine
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

